Facebook Pixel
Logo for The Glow Up

The Top 5 Mascaras For Mature Women, According To Beauty Editors

We did the research so you don't have to 👀

ByEditorial TeamFeb 18, 2024

Let’s face it: as we age, our lashes face their own set of challenges. They become thinner and more delicate, and let’s not forget the dreaded smudging issue that can make us look more raccoon than ravishing. But fear not! After numerous trials, giggles, and a few eye winks, we’ve uncovered the top five mascaras that stood out not just in our hearts but also on our lashes.

1. PrimeLash by Prime Prometics ($28)

This little gem from Prime Prometics has truly redefined what mascara can do, especially for those with mature eyes. The standout feature has to be its wand. It’s meticulously designed to separate and coat each lash individually, ensuring a flawless application every single time. No clumps, no mess, just beautifully defined lashes.

What we really love is PrimeLash is not just makeup; it’s also a nourishing treatment for your lashes. Packed with conditioning agents and fortifying elements, it’s gentle on the most sensitive eyes. It’s formulated to strengthen lashes over time, something you don’t get from your average mascara.

2. Extreme Length Mascara + Lash Primer by Honest ($19.99)

This Honest mascara was an interesting surprise. One end is a lash primer, and the other is the mascara itself. It’s like getting two products in one sleek package. The formula is tailored for sensitive eyes, so no irritation – a must-have as our eyes become more delicate with age. If you prefer a more natural look, this mascara offers a noticeable enhancement yet remains natural. It’s perfect for everyday wear, adding a touch of elegance without going overboard.

3. LiquidLash by Thrive Causemetics ($25)

This mascara is a standout product, especially for those with mature eyes who crave simplicity and gentleness in their beauty regimen. The formula provides incredible length and volume that withstands the challenges of the day – no smudging or flaking. Yet, when it’s time to say goodnight, it slides off effortlessly with just warm water.

4. Telescopic Original Mascara by L’Oreal ($11.99)

What really impressed us was how this mascara delivers extraordinary length. Each application made our lashes look significantly longer, creating a youthful and captivating look. The slender, finely-bristled wand reaches even the smallest lashes, perfect for when you want a sophisticated look. Another aspect we loved about the Telescopic Original is its staying power. It stays put throughout the day without smudging, yet it’s lightweight enough not to weigh down our lashes. Overall, it was a great drugstore option for mature eyes.

5. Pillow Talk Push-Up Lashes Mascara by Charlotte Tilbury ($29)

It’s impossible to write a list of mascaras without mentioning the cult favorite Pillow Talk. We loved how it effortlessly adds both volume and lift. The formula creates an eye-opening effect that instantly rejuvenates your entire look. The elegant packaging and the sumptuous formula make it a luxurious product for your makeup routine. We would say, though, this one is more for those days when you want to go for a full-glam, more dramatic eye makeup look.

Why PrimeLash by Prime Prometics Takes the Crown

As our mascara journey comes to a close, it’s clear that while each of the mascaras we tested has its unique charm, PrimeLash by Prime Prometics stands a lash above the rest.

The carefully crafted formula, brimming with ingredients that strengthen and condition, makes it more than just a cosmetic choice. So, if you’re looking for a mascara designed and formulated for mature, sensitive eyes, we recommend giving PrimeLash a try.